Are there any species of fish that are legal to catch with rod and reel but illegal for spear fishing?



  1. 0 Votes

    Any fish that is considered protected or a “Species of Concern” is just fine to catch with a rod and reel — as long as you release it, and as long as you did not set out to catch that species — whereas authorities would not be so sensitive to a spear through the fish.  An example of such a fish is the Bull Trout in Montana.  If you catch a bull trout, you must release it immediately.

  2. 0 Votes

    This certianly can change from state to state. I would reccomend that you take a look at the Fishing Regulations for whichever state you are particularly interested. In some states, spearfishing is not a legal “method of take”. In those instances, all species would be illegal to take with a spear while many species would be legal with a rod and reel.

    It may be important to also note (in regards to the comment by “whitefish”) that in some instances, a state will restrict particular baits (e.g. live bait) or tackle (e.g. use of barbless hooks only) to further minimize the potential for impact on species of concern in a particular water. I am sure Whitefish new this as their answer was a quality one, I just wanted to point this out as well.

Please signup or login to answer this question.

Sorry,At this time user registration is disabled. We will open registration soon!